Skip to main content

Table 5 ANOVA results (F statistic and probability levels) and test of marginal means for the effect of climate, site type, management alternative, and their interaction on EAI, carbon storage (CS), average annual increment in total volume (MAI), sawn wood production (MHsaw), and annual average cone production over the rotation period (CPha and CPtree)

From: A model-based analysis of climate change vulnerability of Pinus pinea stands under multiobjective management in the Northern Plateau of Spain

  

EAI

CS

MAI

MHsaw

CPha

CPtree

 

Climate (C)

19.0***

604.73***

285.2***

49.55***

366.65***

1817.19***

 

Site type (S)

5.54***

236.21***

72.54***

35.38***

57.74***

166.44***

 

Management (M)

1.15 ns

20.64***

3.65*

13.46***

16.79***

6.80*

 

S × C

1.83 ns

15.22***

8.60***

1.65 ns

5.55*

13.95***

 

C × M

0.96 ns

0.85 ns

0.30 ns

0.25 ns

1.95 ns

0.64 ns

 

S × M

1.07 ns

1.11 ns

1.10 ns

0.70 ns

1.79 ns

1.95 ns

Climate scenario

C2/C1

0.62 a

0.84 a

0.88 a

0.76 a

0.47 a

0.55 a

C3/C1

0.31 b

0.47 c

0.59 c

0.31 c

0.09 b

0.12 b

C4/C1

0.56 a

0.63 b

0.73 b

0.55 b

0.47 a

0.54 a

C5/C1

0.22 c

0.22 d

0.42 d

0.15 d

0.05 c

0.07 c

Site type

ST1

0.46 cb

0.81 a

0.82 a

0.73 a

0.40 a

0.44 a

ST2

0.48 b

0.74 b

0.75 b

0.63 a

0.34 b

0.38 b

ST3

0.34 c

0.51 c

0.60 d

0.22 c

0.19 c

0.25 c

ST4

0.53 a

0.37 d

0.67 c

0.00 d

0.12 d

0.21 d

ST5

0.43 cb

0.52 c

0.61 d

0.38 b

0.36 b

0.39 b

ST6

0.32 c

0.29 e

0.48 e

0.15 c

0.22 c

0.24 c

Management

CP

0.44 a

0.58 a

0.66 a

0.52 a

0.31 a

0.33 a

TP

0.41 a

0.49 c

0.63 b

0.35 b

0.23 b

0.30 b

CNP

0.43 a

0.54 b

0.67 a

0.43 ba

0.28 a

0.33 a

  1. Different letter indicates significant differences between levels for a given factor. Sensitivity value is computed as the value estimated for a given climate scenario (C2 to C5) divided by the value estimated under the baseline climate conditions (C1) (n = 72)
  2. CP cone production, TP timber production, CTP combination of cone and timber production
  3. Probability levels are indicated as *P ≤ 0.05,**P ≤ 0.01, ***P ≤ 0.001, ns: P > 0.05