Skip to main content

Table 1 Silvicultural operations and associated benefits as a function of rotation length

From: Are 40 years better than 55? An analysis of the reduction of forest rotation to cope with drought events in a Douglas fir stand

Operations (year)

Benefits for long rotation (LR) in €/ha

Benefits for short rotation (SR) in €/ha

Harvested (stems/ha)

Harvested volume in m3/ha

Initial costs

− 1915

− 1915

  

Maintenance (1)

− 150

− 350

  

Maintenance (2)

− 200

− 200

  

Maintenance (3)

− 150

   

Maintenance (4)

 

− 200

  

Maintenance (5)

− 200

   

Maintenance (16)

− 700

   

Thinning (20)

 

2318

508

92

Thinning (22)

1344

 

385

70

Thinning (25)

 

1676

150

57

Thinning (29)

1950

 

180

67

Thinning (30)

 

2277

100

59

Harvest (40)

 

29,878

342

503

Thinning (42)

7179

 

190

143

Thinning (48)

5058

 

70

90

Harvest (55)

38,372

 

275

612

NPVa

NPVLR = 16,873

NPVSR = 14,735

  
  1. Source: Institute for Forest Development (IDF) and the Société Forestière de la Caisse des Dépôts et Consignations (SFCDC)
  2. aAuthor’s calculations