Skip to main content

Table 1 Most parsimonious (ΔAIC = 0) and competing models [ΔAIC ≤ 2, indicating substantial support (Burnham and Anderson 2002)] for response variables. Where a competing model for a response was the null model, no entry is made in this table. The complete set of results is reported in Appendices 00. For each response variable, plot data were analyzed using linear mixed models with “site” as the random factor. Predictor variables tested were the measures of EAB-caused ash decline (ADI, AMI), non-ash stand basal area (BA), subcanopy BA, and shrub cover. Topography (upland or wet) was included as a predictor variable if ADI or AMI was included in the most parsimonious or competing model and there was suitable replication within each topographic category. AICc is the small sample Akaike’s information criterion; ∆AIC is the difference between the AICc of a model and the AICc of the best model, and w is Akaike’s weight. ADI represents ash decline index and AMI represents ash mortality index. Statistics reported are based on likelihood ratio and goodness-of-fit tests

From: Release and suppression: forest layer responses to emerald ash borer (Agrilus planipennis)-caused ash death

Response

Predictor models

AICc

ΔAICc

w

Non-ash stand BA RGR

ADI

− 240.25

0.00

0.57

AMI

− 238.70

1.54

0.26

Non-ash stand BA RGR (with topography)

ADI + topography

− 241.86

0.00

0.35

Topography

− 240.99

0.87

0.23

ADI

− 240.25

1.61

0.16

AMI + topography

− 240.10

1.76

0.14

Maple stand BA RGR

AMI

− 188.81

0.00

0.63

ADI

− 187.01

1.80

0.26

Survival: shade-tolerant native seedlings

Subcanopy BA

227.64

0.00

0.55

Recruitment: introduced seedlings

Subcanopy BA

278.81

0.00

0.43

Abundance: introduced seedlings

ADI + shrub cover

333.72

0.00

0.46

 

AMI + shrub % cover

334.58

0.85

0.30

 

Shrub cover

335.38

1.66

0.20

Abundance: introduced seedlings (with topography)

ADI + shrub cover + topography

341.28

0.00

0.36

 

AMI + shrub cover + topography

341.61

0.41

0.29

 

Shrub cover + topography

341.59

0.31

0.30

Sugar maple seedling RGR

ADI + subcanopy BA

30.82

0.00

0.60