Table 2 Cross table of all core publications comprising the main important criteria and factors that can be assigned to these publications
Reference | Peer-reviewed | Country | Evidencelevel | Study type | Studyduration[years] | Type of regenerationfelling | Lightavailabilityquantified | Light toheight growthrelationship | Total cost ofregenerationefforts | Minimum gapsize suggested [ha] | Number ofmain successfactors graduallyconsidered |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Annighöfer et al. (2015) | Yes | GER | 3 | Experiment | 3 | SW | Yes | No | 4 | ||
Annighöfer et al. (2019) | Yes | GER | 4 | Experiment | 1 | SW | Yes | Yes | 2 | ||
No | BEL | 3 | Experiment | 4 | SW | Yes | Yes | 2 | |||
Bilke (2004) | No | GER | 3 | Experiment | n.a. | GSF | No | No | < 0.3 | 3 | |
Bonneau (1996) | Yes | FRA | 4 | Experiment | 9 | No | No | 0 | |||
Brezina and Dobrovolny (2011) | Yes | CZE | 3 | Experiment | 4 | SW, GSF, CC | Yes | Yes | < 0.3 | 4 | |
Bruciamacchie et al. (1994) | No | FRA | 4 | Experiment | n.a. | GSF | No | No | < 0.3 | 2 | |
Chaar and Colin (1999) | Yes | FRA | 4 | Experiment | 2 | SW | No | No | 0 | ||
Dohrenbusch (1996) | No | GER | 4 | Experiment | 8 | SW, CC | Yes | Yes | 2 | ||
No | GER | 4 | Experiment | 1 | GSF | Yes | Yes | 0.2–0.3 | 3 | ||
Fischer and West (1991) | No | GER | 6 | Expert knowledge | SW | 0 | |||||
Yes | SWE | 2 | Experiment | 7 | SW | Yes | Yes | 2 | |||
Hager (1994) | No | GER | 4 | Experiment | 1 | GSF | Yes | Yes | 3 | ||
Hauskeller-Bullerjahn (1997); *Hauskeller-Bullerjahn et al. 2000) | No | GER | 3 | Experiment | 5 | SW | Yes | Yes | 2 | ||
Heuer et al. (2006) | No | GER | 3 | Experiment | 4 | SW, GSF | Yes | Yes | 0.1 | 1 | |
Humphrey and Swaine (1997a) | Yes | GBR | 3 | Experiment | 3 | nG | Yes | No | 0.5–1.0 | 1 | |
Humphrey and Swaine (1997b) | Yes | GBR | 4 | Experiment | 2 | nG | No | No | 2 | ||
Jaloviar et al. (2014) | Yes | SLO | 4 | Experiment | 1 | SW | Yes | Yes | 2 | ||
Karius (2004) | No | GER | 6 | Expert knowledge | SW, CC | 0 | |||||
No | SUI | 3 | Experiment | 1 | GSF | No | No | < 0.3 | 2 | ||
Kelly (2002) | Yes | IRL | 4 | Experiment | 25 | GSF | Yes | No | 3 | ||
Kollár (2017) | Yes | HUN | 3 | Experiment | 2 | GSF | Yes | Yes | < 0.1 | 2 | |
Kuehne et al. (2014a) | Yes | GER | 6 | Expert knowledge | SSF, nG, SW, CC | Min. 1.0 | 0 | ||||
Laurent (2016); *Laurent et al. (2017a), Laurent et al. (2017b) | Yes | FRA | 4 | Experiment | 1 | Yes | Yes | 2 | |||
Ligot (2014); *Ligot et al. (2014a); Ligot et al. (2014b); Ligot et al. (2013) | Yes | BEL | 2 | Experiment | 5 | SSF | Yes | Yes | 0.05 | 3 | |
Yes | GER | 3 | Experiment | 8 | SW, GSF, CC | Yes | Yes | > 0.3 | 2 | ||
von Lüpke (2008) | Yes | GER | 5 | Experiment | 13 | GSF, CC | Yes | Yes | > 0.25 | 2 | |
Mechler and Lieber (2000) | No | GER | 6 | Expert knowledge | SW | < 0.3 | 0 | ||||
Modrow (2016); *Modrow & Pyttel (2019); Modrow et al. (2020) | Yes | GER | 4 | Experiment | 1 | GSF | Yes | Yes | > 0.2 | 3 | |
Mölder et al. (2017) | Yes | GER | 6 | Literature review | GSF | Depending onmanagementgoals | 0 | ||||
Mölder et al. (2019a) | Yes | GER | 6 | Literature review | 0 | ||||||
Mölder et al. (2019b) | Yes | GER | 3 | Experiment | 2 | 3 | |||||
Nebout (2009) | No | FRA | 6 | Expert knowledge | Yes | No | Depending onmanagementgoals | 0 | |||
Nicolini et al. (2000) | Yes | FRA | 5 | Experiment | 5 | SW | 2500–3600 | 1 | |||
No | GER | 5 | Experiment | n.a. | nG | Yes | Yes | 1 | |||
Petritan et al. (2013) | Yes | ROU | 5 | Experiment | 1 | GSF | No | No | < 0.3 | 2 | |
Pisoke and Spiecker (1997) | No | GER | 5 | Experiment | n.a. | nG | No | No | 0 | ||
proQuercus (2010) | No | SUI | 6 | Expert knowledge | GSF | No | No | 0 | |||
proQuercus (2013) | No | FRA | 6 | Expert knowledge | Min. 1.0 | 0 | |||||
Rößler et al. (2019) | No | GER | 5 | Experiment | 1 | SW, GSF | 2 | ||||
Rumpf (2011) | No | GER | 6 | Expert knowledge | SW | Yes | Yes | 14,000 | Min. 1.0 | 0 | |
Sanchez and Auquière (2015) | No | FRA | 6 | Expert knowledge | 0.3–0.5 | 0 | |||||
Scheeder (1989) | No | GER | 6 | Expert knowledge | GSF | 0.1–1.0 | 0 | ||||
Schürg (2013) | No | GER | 4 | Experiment | 1 | SSF | Yes | No | 2 | ||
Spellmann (2001) | No | GER | 5 | Experiment | 5 | No | No | 2 | |||
Stahl-Streit (2004) | No | GER | 6 | Expert knowledge | SSF | 0 | |||||
Tinya et al. (2019) | Yes | HUN | 3 | Experiment | 1 | SW | Yes | No | 2 | ||
Tobisch (2009) | No | HUN | 4 | Experiment | 4 | GSF | Yes | Yes | 2 | ||
van Cleve (2012) | No | GER | 5 | Experiment | 2 | GSF | Yes | No | 2 | ||
van Couwenberghe et al. (2010) | Yes | FRA | 3 | Experiment | 1 | nG | No | No | 2 | ||
van Couwenberghe et al. (2013) | Yes | FRA | 4 | Experiment | 4 | GSF | Yes | Yes | 2 | ||
Wilhelm and Rieger (2013) | No | GER | 6 | Expert knowledge | GSF | < 0.3 | 0 | ||||
Wilhelm et al. (2019) | No | GER | 6 | Expert knowledge | GSF | < 0.1 | 0 |