Skip to main content

Table 2 Average concentrations (g kg-1) of major nutrients in stems, both including bark, according to Jacobsen et al. (2003) and this paper and the relative difference (%) between both datasets (% difference = (this paper / Jacobsen et al. – 1) x 100%)

From: Impacts of harvesting methods on nutrient removal in Dutch forests exposed to high-nitrogen deposition

Species

Nutrient concentrations (g kg-1)

N

P

S

Ca

K

Mg

Jacobsen et al. (2003)

 Larch

1.21

0.32

n.a.

0.74

0.73

0.26

 Spruce

1.22

0.15

n.a.

1.41

0.77

0.18

 Fir

1.01

0.13

n.a.

0.75

0.87

0.12

 Pine

1.09

0.11

n.a.

1.08

0.65

0.24

 Birch

1.70

0.17

n.a.

1.20

0.75

0.20

 Beech

1.54

0.14

n.a.

1.80

1.04

0.26

 Oak

2.10

0.12

n.a.

2.47

1.05

0.18

This paper and difference this paper vs. Jacobsen et al. (2003)

 Larch

1.60(+32%)

0.0565 (-82%)

0.0875

0.403 (-46%)

0.383 (-47%)

0.0980 (-62%)

 Spruce

1.68 (+38%)

0.0646 (-57%)

0.0852

1.528 (+8%)

0.620 (-19%)

0.204 (+13%)

 Fir

1.54 (+52%)

0.0548 (-58%)

0.0834

0.428 (-43%)

0.494 (-43%)

0.0949 (-21%)

 Pine

1.60 (+47%)

0.0689 (-37%)

0.0987

0.768 (-29%)

0.471 (-28%)

0.162 (-32%)

 Birch

2.12 (+25%)

0.0908 (-47%)

0.103

0.765 (-36%)

0.601 (-20%)

0.253 (+26%)

 Beech

2.31 (+50%)

0.102 (-27%)

0.138

1.392 (-23%)

0.983 (-5%)

0.265 (+2%)

 Oak

2.99 (+42%)

0.0889 (-26%)

0.186

1.763 (-29%)

0.865 (-18%)

0.171 (-5%)