Skip to main content

Table 3 Characteristics of RBF and MLP-based ANNs and associated metrics for model evaluation

From: Analysis of plot-level volume increment models developed from machine learning methods applied to an uneven-aged mixed forest

Index

Structure

Algorithm

Error function

Hidden activation

R2

RMSE

%RMSE

BIAS

%BIAS

1

MLP 7-12-1

BFGS 11

SOS

Logistic

0.928

0.24

10.81

0.011

0.5394

2

MLP 7-5-1

BFGS 14

SOS

Identity

0.930

0.21

9.451

0.016

0.7316

3

MLP 7-9-1

BFGS 11

SOS

Identity

0.930

0.21

9.451

0.014

0.6685

4

MLP 7-10-1

BFGS 16

SOS

Identity

0.926

0.24

10.810

0.007

0.3391

5

MLP 7-11-1

BFGS 11

SOS

Tanh

0.936

0.19

8.558

0.004

0.2021

6

RBF 7-24-1

RBFT

SOS

Gaussian

0.862

0.29

13.063

0.009

0.3132

7

RBF 7-30-1

RBFT

SOS

Gaussian

0.893

0.25

10.810

0.023

1.0520

8

RBF 7-27-1

RBFT

SOS

Gaussian

0.861

0.28

12.6126

0.039

1.7651

9

RBF 7-30-1

RBFT

SOS

Gaussian

0.858

0.26

11.711

0.006

0.2926

10

RBF 7-29-1

RBFT

SOS

Gaussian

0.901

0.27

12.162

0.018

0.852